TrustedPros vs HomeStars: Which Platform Is Right For You?

When Canadian homeowners search for reliable contractors, two names often come up: HomeStars and TrustedPros. Both platforms aim to connect homeowners with local professionals, but they differ significantly in scale, reputation, review verification, and lead quality. While HomeStars is Canada’s largest and most established referral network, TrustedPros has faced criticism regarding authenticity, lead performance, and customer service.

Overview

HomeStars has become Canada’s leading contractor referral platform, with 12,500+ pros, 1.5 million completed jobs, and nearly one million verified reviews. It is structured around building consumer trust through strong review verification, a scorecard system, and transparent pay-per-lead pricing for contractors. Homeowners can post jobs for free, and pros only pay if they are contacted.

TrustedPros, founded in 2004, offers a similar matchmaking service but operates on a smaller scale. While it provides a “TrustScore” system for evaluating contractors, the platform has been criticized for questionable review practices, fewer leads, and inconsistent customer service.

Differences in Review & Trust Systems

HomeStars

HomeStars has invested heavily in ensuring review credibility. Its review verification system combines a scorecard with a recommendation meter to help separate genuine customer experiences from marketing noise. This transparency builds confidence for homeowners while helping contractors showcase legitimate feedback.

TrustedPros

TrustedPros uses a TrustScore rating system designed to evaluate performance, authenticity, and business practices. However, some users report issues with review filtering, including blocked or removed negative reviews and concerns about fake or manipulated reviews. This has raised questions about the platform’s accountability and fairness.

Lead Quality & Quantity

HomeStars

Pros generally report that HomeStars provides more consistent, higher-quality leads that convert better. The platform attracts engaged homeowners who are actively searching for contractors, which helps increase conversion rates for pros who maintain strong profiles.

TrustedPros

TrustedPros leads are often described as fewer and less reliable. Some contractors report that the volume of leads and marketing exposure does not justify the fees. As a result, TrustedPros may not deliver the same return on investment compared to HomeStars.

Pricing & Business Model

HomeStars

HomeStars uses a pay-per-lead model. Contractors can sign up for free, list their services, and choose which leads to pursue. Fees are only charged when a homeowner contacts them, making the pricing structure more transparent and performance-based.

TrustedPros

TrustedPros’ pricing model is less transparent. While it charges fees for pros, many users feel that the costs do not align with the quality or quantity of leads provided. This has contributed to negative feedback from some contractors regarding value for money.

Customer Service & Reputation

HomeStars

HomeStars maintains a positive reputation overall. While contractors need to invest effort to maintain top placement in listings, many report that the platform reliably connects them with interested homeowners. Its proactive verification and large user base have helped it build credibility across Canada.

TrustedPros

TrustedPros has received multiple complaints from contractors and homeowners. Issues include poor contractor accountability, unaddressed customer disputes, fake reviews, unfair moderation of negative feedback, and slow or unhelpful customer service responses. These recurring concerns have impacted its industry reputation.

Summary Table

Which Should You Choose?

• Choose HomeStars if you want access to Canada’s largest, most trusted network of contractors, backed by verified reviews, transparent pricing, and consistent lead quality. It is particularly strong for pros in competitive trades who want reliable exposure and for homeowners who value credibility.
  
• Be cautious with TrustedPros due to reports of questionable review practices, customer disputes, and inconsistent lead quality. While it may be an option for contractors with smaller budgets, expectations should be managed regarding return on investment and reputation support.
  

Conclusion

Both TrustedPros and HomeStars aim to connect Canadian homeowners with qualified professionals, but their effectiveness and trustworthiness differ. HomeStars stands out as the preferred choice thanks to its scale, review verification, pay-per-lead transparency, and overall reputation. TrustedPros, while established, has struggled with credibility and service issues that limit its effectiveness compared to HomeStars.

For Canadian homeowners and contractors looking for quality connections, HomeStars is generally the safer and more effective platform. TrustedPros may still play a role for some, but businesses and homeowners should weigh the risks before relying on it.

Take Control of Your Leads with 7ten

Platforms like HomeStars and TrustedPros can help contractors find work, but they also come with fees, competition, and limited control. At 7ten, we help Canadian contractors own their lead generation with proven PPC and SEO strategies that drive exclusive, high-quality leads straight to their business.

Instead of paying for shared or unreliable leads, we’ll help you build a steady pipeline of homeowners actively searching for your services. With 7ten, you’re not just another profile in a directory—you’re the first call customers make.

Work with 7ten today and take control of your marketing, your leads, and your growth.