Angi vs Thumbtack: Which Platform is Best for Your Business?

When it comes to lead generation for service professionals, choosing the right platform can make a significant difference in your business’s success. Two of the most popular options are Angi (formerly Angie’s List) and Thumbtack. Both platforms connect service providers with potential clients, but they cater to slightly different audiences and have unique ways of delivering leads.

For home services sector specifically professionals seeking targeted leads, Angi’s niche focus provides access to an audience already primed for your services. However, if you operate in multiple industries or offer varied services, Thumbtack’s broader reach might help you tap into different customer bases. Whether you’re focused on roofing lead generation or expanding your HVAC lead generation, platforms like Angi and Thumbtack offer powerful tools to grow your business.

Business Focus

One of the most significant differences between Angi and Thumbtack lies in their business focus.

Angi: As a platform, Angi primarily caters to home service professionals. If your business specializes in services like home repair, renovation, or maintenance, Angi’s focus is tailored to your industry. The platform offers listings for around 720 specific home improvement and repair services, allowing you to connect directly with customers looking for these particular solutions.

Thumbtack: In contrast, Thumbtack has a broader reach. Covering more than 900 unique services across 13 distinct industries, Thumbtack goes beyond home services to include areas such as event planning, personal care, fitness, business services, and more. This diversity makes Thumbtack an appealing choice for businesses outside the home services niche or for those offering a wide range of services.

Lead Generation Models

The way each platform generates leads is another critical difference.

Angi: Angi operates much like a traditional directory. Businesses list their services on the platform, and customers search for providers based on their specific needs. Once a customer finds a listing that suits them, they can contact the service provider directly. This method puts control in the hands of the customers and requires businesses to ensure their listings are highly visible and attractive to potential clients.

Thumbtack: Thumbtack, on the other hand, uses a matching system. Professionals sign up, create detailed profiles, and specify the types of jobs they can take on. Thumbtack then matches them with potential clients based on their preferences, experience, and service capabilities. This allows for a more personalized experience, as professionals receive direct requests that align with their skillset, instead of relying solely on customers finding their listing.

Which Lead Generation System is Better?

Both models have their pros and cons. If you prefer a hands-on approach where you actively manage your listings and attract customers with compelling offers, Angi may be the better option. However, if you like the idea of being directly connected with clients without waiting for them to find you, Thumbtack’s matching system offers a more proactive way to generate leads.

Pricing Models

Pricing can be a dealbreaker when it comes to choosing a lead generation platform, and Angi and Thumbtack take different approaches.

Angi: While it is free to join Angi, businesses are charged fees to advertise their services and become more visible in customer searches. Angi’s pricing model is negotiable based on your advertising needs, and there is no flat annual fee for basic functionalities. The costs can add up, especially for smaller businesses, but the larger reach and access to premium leads can justify the expense.

Thumbtack: Thumbtack uses a credit system, where professionals buy credits to communicate with leads. Each lead costs a certain number of credits, which can vary depending on the job’s complexity, demand, and location. This system is pay-as-you-go, and there is no annual flat fee, allowing professionals to control their costs more effectively.

For those looking for a low-cost, flexible option, Thumbtack’s credit system allows you to scale your spending according to the number of leads you pursue. However, if you’re willing to invest more upfront for potentially higher-quality leads, Angi’s advertising model may be worth the expense.

Review Systems

Both platforms use customer reviews to help businesses build trust and reputation, but their systems differ.

For businesses with a solid reputation and the ability to maintain high grades, Angi’s report card system can work in their favor by showcasing their expertise. However, if you’re new to the market or prefer a more straightforward review process, Thumbtack’s star ratings may provide a faster way to build credibility.

Competition

Angi: Angi tends to attract more established professionals with years of experience and well-developed reputations. This allows them to charge premium rates, but it also means that competition can be fierce, and standing out can require significant investment in advertising.

Thumbtack: Thumbtack’s broader marketplace includes a wider range of professionals, from newer businesses to highly experienced ones. This diversity can create price competition, especially in service categories where there are many providers offering similar services. As a result, pricing may be lower, but businesses may have more opportunities to win jobs based on competitive rates.

If you’re an established business with a strong portfolio and the ability to command higher rates, Angi may provide a platform where you can thrive. On the other hand, if you’re looking to build your reputation or compete in multiple service categories, Thumbtack offers a more diverse playing field.

Reach and User Base

Angi: As a leader in the home services industry, Angi has a larger reach in this specific niche. If you’re primarily focused on home improvement or repair, Angi’s user base is highly targeted, meaning you’re more likely to connect with serious clients looking for your services.

Thumbtack: Thumbtack, by contrast, has a smaller pool of providers for each service category, but it boasts over 10 million users across various industries. This makes Thumbtack a better choice for businesses looking to offer services in multiple categories or for those who want to tap into diverse markets.

For businesses aiming to dominate home services, Angi’s niche market provides access to a dedicated audience. For those with a broader offering or who want to diversify, Thumbtack’s wide user base provides more opportunities to attract leads across different sectors.

Which Platform is Right for You?

The choice between Angi and Thumbtack ultimately depends on your business goals, industry, and marketing strategy. Both platforms can be powerful tools for generating leads, but understanding their key differences will help you choose the one that best fits your business’s needs and marketing budget.

Looking to grow your service business and reach more clients? Whether you’re considering Angi or Thumbtack, the right digital marketing strategy can help you stand out from the competition. At 7ten Digital Marketing, we specialize in optimizing your online presence, driving high-quality leads, and maximizing your ROI on platforms like Angi and Thumbtack. Let us help you make the most of these lead generation tools with tailored SEO, PPC, and content strategies that attract your ideal clients. Contact 7ten Digital Marketing today and take your business to the next level!

Claudia Watson

See Full Bio